Everton Captaincy Decision: Who Will Lead the Blues?

Everton need to appoint a new captain after Seamus Coleman's retirement, and the decision will be made before the Premier League campaign gets underway against Crystal Palace on August 22. The obvious choice would be James Tarkowski, who has effectively been the team's captain over the past two seasons given Coleman's limited appearances.

Who Should Be the New Captain?

Our writers have their say on who should be the new captain. Connor O'Neill thinks that Jarrad Branthwaite should be the new captain, citing his ability and presence on the field. He also mentions that Branthwaite has captaincy potential, having skippered Lee Carsley's England Under-21s in the last-ever international match at Goodison Park on November 21, 2023.

Why It Matters for Everton

The decision to appoint a new captain is crucial for Everton, as it will set the tone for the new season. The new captain will be expected to lead the team on and off the field, and will be a key figure in the team's success.

What Comes Next?

The decision on who will be the new captain will be made in the coming weeks, and the team will be expected to announce the new captain before the start of the new season. The new captain will be expected to lead the team to success, and will be a key figure in the team's future.

Everton are currently 13th in the Premier League table, with 49 points from 38 games. They have scored 47 goals and conceded 50, and are 36 points behind leaders Arsenal. Their recent form has been poor, with a loss to Tottenham on May 24, 2026, and a draw with Ipswich on May 31, 2026. They will be looking to improve their form in the coming weeks and months.

The new captain will be expected to lead the team to success, and will be a key figure in the team's future. The decision on who will be the new captain will be made in the coming weeks, and the team will be expected to announce the new captain before the start of the new season.