Everton have been told to demand at least £100 million for James Garner this summer if Aston Villa come in for the midfielder. The Toffees finished 13th in the Premier League last season, four points off eighth place, and Garner was a key part of their midfield under David Moyes.
Why Everton fans want £100m for Garner
Fans took to X after reports that Villa are interested in the England international, insisting the club should not let him go for less than £100m. Garner made 41 appearances last season, scoring three goals and providing seven assists in all competitions. His versatility allowed Moyes to use him in multiple positions, and his consistent performances have made him a valuable asset to the squad.
The Midlands club have been long-term admirers of Garner, who was reliable in every game he played. With transfer fees for midfielders reaching record highs this summer, Everton supporters believe Garner’s homegrown status and ability justify a £100m price tag. The Toffees have not made major moves yet this window, but Moyes is building a side capable of pushing for European football this season.
How Garner performed last season
According to Fotmob on 24 July, Garner averaged 0.05 goals, 0.05 xG, 1.19 shots, 0.18 assists, and 1.48 chances created per 90 minutes in the Premier League. He also won 61.3% of his duels, made 3.16 tackles, 1.56 interceptions, and 2.24 clearances per 90. His ability to impact both attack and defence makes him a player hard to replace.
Garner’s homegrown status adds to his value, as finding a direct replacement would be difficult. Everton’s recent form saw them lose their last three games, including a 1-0 defeat to Tottenham on 24 May 2026, and they sit 36 points behind Arsenal in the title race. The club’s next fixture is against Ipswich at home on 19 September 2026, giving Moyes time to strengthen the squad before then.
